Hotel A
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira
Portugal
Hotel B
Santiago de Alfama Lisbon
Portugal
vs
Honeymoon Hotel Head-to-Head
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira vs Santiago de Alfama Lisbon
Two of the world's most coveted honeymoon hotels, scored on what actually matters for couples.
Our Verdict
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira scores 90/100 on our honeymoon rubric; Santiago de Alfama Lisbon scores 90/100. It's a tie edges this head-to-head, but read the criteria below — the right pick depends on what you value most.
Pick Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira for...
- ◆Pick Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira if Portugal (Portugal) is the trip you really want.
- ◆Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira is a 5-star property with 9.4 TripAdvisor.
Pick Santiago de Alfama Lisbon for...
- ◆Santiago de Alfama Lisbon starts at $400/night — easier on the budget.
- ◆82% of Santiago de Alfama Lisbon reviews are from couples — the romance signal is strong.
- ◆Pick Santiago de Alfama Lisbon if Portugal (Portugal) is the trip you really want.
Side-by-side
At a glance — 12 criteria
1
Belmond Reid's wins
3
Santiago de wins
Criterion
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira
Santiago de Alfama Lisbon
Honeymoon Score
90/100
90/100
Price / night
$500–$1,800
✓$400–$1,500
Stars
5★
5★
Adults-only
No
No
Beach access
No
No
Spa
Yes
Yes
Pool
✓Yes
No
Room service
No
No
Couples reviews
78%
✓82%
TripAdvisor
9.4/10
✓9.5/10
Country
Portugal
Portugal
Destination
Portugal
Portugal
Portugal
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira
90/100·$500–$1,800/night
Portugal
Santiago de Alfama Lisbon
90/100·$400–$1,500/night
Common questions
FAQ
Which is more expensive — Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira or Santiago de Alfama Lisbon?+
Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira is the pricier of the two ($500–$1,800/night vs $400–$1,500/night for Santiago de Alfama Lisbon).
Which is adults-only — Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira or Santiago de Alfama Lisbon?+
Neither property is strictly adults-only, though both attract a predominantly adult clientele.
Does Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira or Santiago de Alfama Lisbon have overwater bungalows?+
Neither property offers overwater villas.
When is the best month to visit Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira and Santiago de Alfama Lisbon?+
For Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira in Portugal, aim for the dry shoulder season; for Santiago de Alfama Lisbon in Portugal, the same logic applies — check our destination guides for month-by-month detail.
Is Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira better than Santiago de Alfama Lisbon for a honeymoon?+
On our honeymoon rubric Belmond Reid's Palace Madeira scores 90/100 versus Santiago de Alfama Lisbon at 90/100 — but the right pick depends on whether you prioritise destination and ambience.
Still comparing?
More hotel head-to-heads
Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Amanyara Turks Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Ambergris Cay Private Island Resort Turks Caicos All Inclusive Turks And Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Como Parrot Cay Turks And Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs The Palms Turks And Caicos Turks And Caicos→Aman Kyoto Japan vs Hoshinoya Kyoto Japan→Aman Kyoto Japan vs Jade Mountain St Lucia→