Hotel A
Helena Bay Lodge
New Zealand
Hotel B
Matakauri Lodge
New Zealand
vs
Honeymoon Hotel Head-to-Head
Helena Bay Lodge vs Matakauri Lodge
Two of the world's most coveted honeymoon hotels, scored on what actually matters for couples.
Our Verdict
Helena Bay Lodge scores 90/100 on our honeymoon rubric; Matakauri Lodge scores 90/100. It's a tie edges this head-to-head, but read the criteria below — the right pick depends on what you value most.
Pick Helena Bay Lodge for...
- ◆Helena Bay Lodge wins on the beach.
- ◆78% of Helena Bay Lodge reviews are from couples — the romance signal is strong.
- ◆Helena Bay Lodge offers beach — not available at Matakauri Lodge.
Pick Matakauri Lodge for...
- ◆Matakauri Lodge starts at $1,300/night — easier on the budget.
- ◆Matakauri Lodge offers lake — not available at Helena Bay Lodge.
- ◆Pick Matakauri Lodge if New Zealand (New Zealand) is the trip you really want.
Side-by-side
At a glance — 12 criteria
3
Helena Bay wins
1
Matakauri Lodge wins
Criterion
Helena Bay Lodge
Matakauri Lodge
Honeymoon Score
90/100
90/100
Price / night
$2,200–$6,500
✓$1,300–$4,200
Stars
5★
5★
Adults-only
No
No
Beach access
✓Yes
No
Spa
Yes
Yes
Pool
Yes
Yes
Room service
Yes
Yes
Couples reviews
✓78%
75%
TripAdvisor
✓9.6/10
9.5/10
Country
New Zealand
New Zealand
Destination
New Zealand
New Zealand
New Zealand
Helena Bay Lodge
90/100·$2,200–$6,500/night
New Zealand
Matakauri Lodge
90/100·$1,300–$4,200/night
Common questions
FAQ
Which is more expensive — Helena Bay Lodge or Matakauri Lodge?+
Helena Bay Lodge is the pricier of the two ($2,200–$6,500/night vs $1,300–$4,200/night for Matakauri Lodge).
Which is adults-only — Helena Bay Lodge or Matakauri Lodge?+
Neither property is strictly adults-only, though both attract a predominantly adult clientele.
Does Helena Bay Lodge or Matakauri Lodge have overwater bungalows?+
Neither property offers overwater villas.
When is the best month to visit Helena Bay Lodge and Matakauri Lodge?+
For Helena Bay Lodge in New Zealand, aim for the dry shoulder season; for Matakauri Lodge in New Zealand, the same logic applies — check our destination guides for month-by-month detail.
Is Helena Bay Lodge better than Matakauri Lodge for a honeymoon?+
On our honeymoon rubric Helena Bay Lodge scores 90/100 versus Matakauri Lodge at 90/100 — but the right pick depends on whether you prioritise beach (Helena Bay Lodge) over lake (Matakauri Lodge).
Still comparing?
More hotel head-to-heads
Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Amanyara Turks Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Ambergris Cay Private Island Resort Turks Caicos All Inclusive Turks And Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs Como Parrot Cay Turks And Caicos→Alexandra Resort Turks And Caicos vs The Palms Turks And Caicos Turks And Caicos→Aman Kyoto Japan vs Hoshinoya Kyoto Japan→Aman Kyoto Japan vs Jade Mountain St Lucia→